If there’s one name synonymous with timeless elegance, it’s Tiffany & Co.—the little blue box alone sparks instant excitement! When I sold my jewelry stores back in 2007, I decided to work for Tiffany & Co. as part of the sales team and as a gemologist. It was quite an exciting, challenging, and worthwhile experience. We were even required to take a class on how to properly tie the white ribbon on each box! So, if you’ve been eyeing a piece of Tiffany jewelry, you might be wondering: Should I just buy new or purchase a pre-owned piece?
Luxury resale is booming, and snagging pre-owned Tiffany & Co. pieces can be a smart move—but is it always worth it? Let’s dive into the pros and cons of buying second-hand Tiffany & Co. jewelry so you can make the best decision for your collection.
Pros of Buying Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co.
1. Significant Cost Savings
Let’s start with the biggest perk: price. Pre-owned Tiffany jewelry often comes at a fraction of the retail price, meaning you can own that iconic Return to Tiffany bracelet, Elsa Peretti Diamonds by the Yard necklace, or a classic Tiffany engagement ring without paying full price.
Example: A brand-new Tiffany T Wire Bracelet can retail for over $3,000, but a well-maintained pre-owned one? You might find it for $2,000 or less.
2. Access to Discontinued & Vintage Pieces
Tiffany & Co. has a rich history, and some of its best designs are no longer in production. Want a 1980s Elsa Peretti Bone Cuff? Or a 1960s Schlumberger piece which exudes Old Hollywood glam? The pre-owned market is your best (and often only) option.
3. Investment-Worthy Pieces at a Discount
Certain Tiffany & Co. designs hold or even increase in value over time. Iconic collections like Schlumberger, Paloma Picasso, and the Tiffany Setting engagement ring remain highly sought after, making pre-owned purchases a smart investment.
Pro Tip: Look for rare or limited-edition pieces which collectors covet.
4. Sustainable & Eco-Friendly
Buying pre-owned jewelry is a sustainable choice! By purchasing secondhand, you’re extending the life of a beautifully crafted piece and reducing the demand for new mining. Tiffany & Co. already champions sustainability, but shopping pre-owned takes it a step further.
5. The Same Luxury Experience—Without the Markup
When you shop from a trusted reseller (like through me and my connection with Fashionphile), you’re still getting authentic Tiffany & Co. quality, the luxury experience, and that signature craftsmanship—just without the hefty price tag.
Cons of Buying Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co.
1. Risk of Counterfeits
Tiffany & Co. is one of the most counterfeited jewelry brands. Some fakes are shockingly convincing, so buying from unverified sellers on eBay, Facebook Marketplace, or random online stores is risky.
Solution: Always buy from trusted resellers (like Fashionphile and private gemologists like me!). These sources authenticate every piece before selling.
2. May Not Come with Original Packaging
While the jewelry is the main attraction, there’s something magical about that Tiffany Blue Box. Some pre-owned pieces may not include original packaging, but this doesn’t impact the quality or value of the piece itself.
Solution: Some resellers provide replacement boxes, or you can source an authentic Tiffany & Co. box separately if that little blue treasure chest matters to you!
3. Limited Resizing & Repairs
Tiffany & Co. sometimes refuses to service or resize pieces which were not purchased directly from their stores.
Solution: Work with a trusted jeweler or gemologist (Yes Me!) to assess whether a piece can be resized or repaired without compromising its value.
4. No Brand Warranty
Tiffany & Co. offers a lifetime warranty on its pieces—but only if you buy directly from them. Pre-owned purchases don’t come with this guarantee.
Solution: If you’re investing in a high-value piece (like an engagement ring), consider jewelry insurance to protect your purchase.
Final Verdict: Is Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co. Worth It?
Absolutely—if you shop smart.
If you want a high-end piece at a lower price, access to vintage designs, and a more sustainable way to shop, the pre-owned market is a goldmine.
But only buy from reputable sources which authenticate their pieces, and be mindful of resale limitations like warranty and resizing.
Looking to add some pre-owned Tiffany & Co. sparkles to your collection? Check out this great opportunity to order through me from Fashionphile – click HERE to learn more. I can help you find authentic luxury pieces at unbeatable prices.
Ready to shop Tiffany & Co. for less? Contact me today and let’s find your dream piece!
